American Renaissance for the Twenty-first Century | Article
Values and Achievement as Portrayed in Sculpture
by Marc Mellon
Do you remember the
Sixties adage, "You are what you eat."? The corollary is:
You are what you art. Our choices of what books to read,
what music to listen to, what movies and theater to attend,
what art to live with—whether as collector or creator—are
analogous to what we choose to eat in this way: Unless we're
suffering from some sort of masochism, we avoid foods that
make us ill. Shouldn't we protect our psyches as well?
Surround yourself with negative individuals, watch TV news,
read the tabloids, and these are bound to affect you
adversely. Decisions about art, literature, and music, made
over time, affect us in a similar way: Consistently choose
discordant over harmonic, chaotic over ordered,
anti-aesthetic over aesthetic, thrown together over
beautifully crafted—and you have a recipe for a soul in
uneasy overload, if not crisis.
So it is with sculpture. Down any random street, in the
plaza of a downtown center, one can find "sculpture" made of
monumental welded I-beams painted nursery school colors—a
vacuous amusement, an inept apology for modern
architecture's lack of warmth and character. The 1960s and
70s saw the human figure, when it was represented at all, as
alienated, depressed, and mutilated—a resin cast of a
clothed figure beaten by club-wielding police; a drug
addict, asleep, overdosed, or dead. Seeking spiritual
nourishment, we are offered spaced-out humanoids,
vacant-faced and gesturally impaired, crudely fashioned from
a plaster body cast much like a death mask. Seeing such
"art" everywhere, it is easy to imagine that we are past
crisis and in aesthetic collapse.
Yet it was not long ago that sculpture was a celebration of
the glory of the human figure. In 1928 the National
Sculpture Society presented an exhibition at the California
Palace of the Legion of Honor in San Francisco. The title of
the handsome hardbound 352-page exhibit catalogue was,
appropriately, Contemporary American Sculpture.
This exhibit was in tribute. The catalogue's preface never
makes this point directly, but the honoring of achievement
was a major part of the sculptor's trade. The work projected
values deemed worthy of the sculptor's efforts and of the
public's attention. There was a basic understanding that
people need principles for guidance and role models for
inspiration, and that fine artists are able to clarify,
articulate, and satisfy these needs aesthetically in the
works they present to the public.
The exhibit included works that today are very familiar: Jo
Davidson's massive bust of a seated larger-than-life
Gertrude Stein evokes an era when artists perhaps had more
time and interest in sharing ideas and camaraderie. D. C.
French's Abraham Lincoln, monumentally and solemnly weighted
with presence, thought, and dignity, stands out as the opus
that it is. Beyond Gertrude Stein, tributes to the arts were
numerous: John Keats, Eugene O'Neill, Pavlova, two dance
works each titled "Joi de Vivre," busts of sculptors Ivan
Mestrovic and Augustus St. Gaudens were all
represented—collectively, a cornucopia of tributes to
creativity. What a pleasure it would be to see today's
literary icons, great sculptors, and dance world legends
similarly honored!
Bronze likenesses of founding fathers George Washington and
Benjamin Franklin were included, as was a bust of legendary
orator Henry Clay—acknowledgement that there is something
known as public service that deserves our respect and
applause. There were some dozen war memorials in homage to
our soldiers, whose courage and patriotism helped us win the
Great War, which had ended not long before. A dozen
religious sculptures including "John the Baptist," "Our Lady
of the Holy Child," "Praying Angel," and "A Monk" were
included, as were several figures with a meditative,
spiritual aspect. Each of these works alluded to the faith,
whether in God or in man, that helps sustain many if not
most of us.
A mythologically inspired "Venus," "Kneeling Venus," "Leda,"
"Diana," and "Actacon" (the latter two by Paul Manship) each
offered a timeless parable. At least a dozen entries by
animiliers, including Anna Hyatt Huntington's "Fawn Running"
and "Jaguar Eating," spoke to an appreciation for the beauty
of nature and the nature of beauty. "The Foundryman" honored
America's blue collar workers and the concept of work. Lief
Ericson's bust, a work titled "First Flight to the North
Pole," and an American Geographical Society Medal gave due
to the courage and vision of explorers. "Spirit of the Sun"
sought to portray native Americans with dignity. A number of
classically inspired female figures meant for fountain,
garden, or atrium were exhibited, all technically fine, each
meant to imbue a beauty of form and spirit, with evocative
if commonly used names like "Inspiration," and "Torso of
Spring."
Now here we are, seventy years later. The chasm couldn't be
greater between the message delivered by the aptly named
Legion of Honor exhibit and the message delivered by today's
"cutting edge" museum shows and magazines.
Comedienne Lily Tomlin once said, "As cynical as I get, I
can't seem to keep up." It's a sad but often appropriate
observation on our times. We are so bombarded with
information, including the goriest details of the private
lives of our public figures, that it's harder than ever to
have role models, never mind heroes. But we need role models
and heroes. Fortunately, individuals, foundations,
corporations and countries still commission portrait busts
and statues to honor their own, so artists today still have
an opportunity to pass these ideals down to our children and
our children's children.
Sculpture can be a unique tribute to achievement. For the
sculptor, the primary aim beyond creating a likeness is to
project the strengths and values of the individuals being
honored. How did they accomplish what they did? Something of
the person's character should be unveiled, the fire in the
belly, the focus, the intensity, the warmth, the strength.
Achievers are often complex people, and something of what
they've overcome to succeed should also project through the
portrait. With all due deference to Leonardo, working in
three dimensions holds a special opportunity by allowing the
sculptor to emphasize strong but often conflicting qualities
from different views. When we view a bust, for example, we
scan the entirety and perceive the subject's nuanced
personality.
As an example of an achiever meeting life's challenges,
consider President George Bush. He overcame being shot down
in the Pacific during World War II, lost a child to
leukemia, was derided and opposed by elements of Left and
Right while rejecting the extremes of both. He served our
country as CIA Director, Vice President, and President.
There needs to be something of his personal passage and many
career milestones in any bust of him. As another example, in
Academy Award-winning actress Patricia Neal's bronze
portrait, nothing was done to hide the lines in her
forehead, as they speak of her inspirational struggle to
come back, as she did, from a massive stroke. R. Brinkley
Smithers' bust projects the warmth and self-deprecating
humor of a legendary alcoholic who transformed himself into
an equally legendary philanthropist. Philadelphia's
monumental statue of Kate Smith singing "God Bless America"
conveys the pleasure this small town, overweight,
oft-slighted girl attained, feeling sexy and light on her
feet, as she took center stage and hit the high notes. To
capture the whole, a portrait artist should know his subject
as well as any biographer.
A side note: For the sake of space we focus here on
sculpture. But in our century, coins and medallions have
actually kept more of their classical use and meaning than
sculpture has. In addition to the familiar profile portrait
of kings and emperors found on coins going back as far as
2,500 years, there are medallions produced to commemorate
almost everything. These include works of the highest level,
by artists such as St. Gaudens and Rodin. The field of coins
and medallions deserves careful study, and its rewards for
the serious art collector are vast.
The subject of medallions leads quite naturally to sports
commemoratives. The growth in this century of college
sports, professional sports, and international events
including the Olympics, has brought corresponding
opportunities for sculptors. There are many sports sculptors
who don't quite hit the mark aesthetically, but the same is
true of portrait sculptors, dance sculptors, and Western
sculptors—the sheer popularity of these themes attracts
multitudes of artists. And as in any time in art history, a
small handful stand out.
Back in the earlier part of the century, the then young
sculptor Frank Eliscu was asked to create several clay
models of football players for what was to be an award for a
college athlete. Naturally, as clients often do, the award's
sponsors didn't pick his favorite model. But the model they
chose became college football's "Heisman Trophy"—an award
even those who know little about sport would likely
recognize. Despite Eliscu's future achievements, it was to
become his best known sculpture.
The appeal in sculpting sport goes beyond the obvious
exhilarating challenge of capturing a beautifully toned
figure in often balletic motion. The athlete's body, his or
her movements and expressions, the act of physically
excelling, are admired by all who aspire to personal
achievement. The passion of the sports fan is perhaps most
intense because the metaphor is so personally meaningful,
poignant and moving to the point of actual tears.
Those who don't enjoy following any sport might want to
rethink their aversion. There is much to be inspired by in
sport: teamwork, finding a second wind, making that extra
effort, attaining a personal best. These concepts are much
more than platitudes: for millions of youngsters, the
hero-worship of great athletes is like a stepping stone to a
wider view of achievement, and the collection and
appreciation of sports art can be an opening onto a wider
aesthetic vista. (For the avowed sports hater, Bud
Greenspan's documentary films chronicling inspiring
individual stories from the Olympic Games are ideal. They
will help anyone better understand why the Greeks treated
their Olympic champions as heroes, and why we should, too.)
Finally, as an exercise in composition and to illustrate the
depth of unmet needs in sculpture today, an exercise is
suggested. Picture two or three great figures, two or three
achievers in whatever field who have not yet been
immortalized in sculpture. Imagine what kind of statue a
proper tribute would involve. For polio vaccine discoverer
Jonas Salk, or for Albert Einstein, or for astronaut and
Senator John Glenn, what would be the ideal setting? The
most eloquent pose?
In answering these questions we come to grips with the hard
specifics of what is valuable in life. In imagining a
statue, we recapture what the person so honored was and is
to us. In seeing the statue built, we experience those
virtues and values with immediacy, as though they were
always with us. As indeed they always should be.
Marc Mellon is well
known for his portrait busts and statues of achievers in
many fields. Included among his works are bronzes honoring
Mickey Mantle, Martina Navratilova, and Agnes de Mille. He
is the creator of the NBA MVP trophy, and this year, he
created the new WNBA trophy for the Women's National
Basketball Association.